Blog

Every so often, the craft beer world delivers a headline so strange it stops even seasoned brewers mid-sip.

This month, that headline is “Nature Calls” — a limited-edition beer reportedly brewed using water infused with bear scat. Yes, actual bear poop!

→ If it sounds like a joke. It’s not!!

The beer is real, intentionally provocative, and already doing exactly what it was designed to do: get people talking. And while the ingredient choice grabs attention, the real lesson here has very little to do with what’s in the mash tun — and everything to do with marketing strategy, risk management, and return on investment.

Let’s break down what’s really going on, and what breweries can actually learn from it.

What Is “Nature Calls”? (And Why Is Everyone Talking About It?)

“Nature Calls” is a limited-release collaboration beer built around a single goal: visibility.

The brewing story is so unexpected that it instantly found its way into headlines, social feeds, group chats, and beer forums. Whether people are intrigued, amused, or mildly horrified, one thing is undeniable:

They’re paying attention.

From a business standpoint, this beer was never meant to become a flagship or drive consistent repeat sales. It exists to:

• Spark conversation
• Create urgency
• Associate the brand with a cultural moment

In other words, the beer itself is temporary — the attention is the product.

Why Novelty Beers Exist (And Why They’re Risky)

Novelty beers have always been part of craft brewing culture:

• Stunt ingredients
• Extreme flavors
• Shock-value names
• Wild collaborations

When done intentionally, they can:

• Drive short-term foot traffic
• Spike social engagement
• Generate earned media and press coverage
• Introduce new customers to a brand

But they also carry real risks — especially if they distract from the beers that actually keep the lights on.

The key question isn’t “Is this weird?”

It’s “Does this serve a clear business purpose — without undermining our core products?”

The Real Lesson: This Isn’t a Beer — It’s a Marketing Campaign

“Nature Calls” isn’t trying to win medals or replace a core SKU. It’s doing something far more strategic:

It’s functioning as a marketing asset.

This kind of release:

• Has a built-in story
• Leverages scarcity
• Creates urgency
• Generates earned media instead of paid ads
• Ties into a larger brand narrative

And that highlights an important truth for brewery owners:

Not every beer needs to be optimized for long-term margin — but every beer needs a reason to exist.

That’s especially important given what we’ve discussed in recent blogs:
core products are still the foundation of a healthy brewery.

Stunt beers like “Nature Calls” can absolutely have a place in your strategy. But they should complement your core lineup, not distract from it. In other words; the problem comes when breweries start treating every release like it needs to be the next viral sensation. That’s when production gets chaotic, costs spiral, and your team loses focus on what actually drives consistent revenue.

A well-executed novelty beer should drive people toward your core products – not replace them.

What Breweries Should Think About Before Doing a Stunt Beer

Before chasing your own headline-grabbing release, it’s critical to evaluate the financial and operational reality behind it.

1. Cost vs. Exposure (The ROI Test)

This is where the math matters.

Ask yourself:

• How much did the batch actually cost?
• What kind of exposure did it generate?
• Would you have paid for that attention otherwise?

Here’s an example:

If a $2,000 specialty batch generates $15,000 worth of media coverage, social reach, and brand visibility you would have otherwise paid for through ads or influencer placements, that’s a 7.5x return on your marketing investment — and not a bad investment at all, as long as you’re actually tracking those metrics.

Most breweries look at the batch cost and taproom revenue in isolation. They miss the bigger picture: brand awareness, foot traffic uplift, first-time customer acquisition, and how many of those customers convert to your core products.

Without tracking, you’re flying blind.

2. Inventory & Waste Risk

Novelty beers have unpredictable demand curves.

• Some sell out instantly
• Others stall after the initial curiosity fades

That means:

• Tight batch sizing matters
• Overproduction quickly turns into waste
• Limited runs should be truly limited

This is another reason core beers matter — they provide stability when experiments miss the mark.

3. Brand Alignment

Not every brewery should do something this extreme.

Ask:

• Does this fit our brand voice?
• Will our core customers get the joke — or feel alienated?
• Does this reinforce what we’re known for, or muddy the message?

Shock without alignment doesn’t build brand equity. It just creates noise.

4. Accounting & Tax Considerations (Often Overlooked)

Even “fun” beers have serious financial implications:

• One-off batches still require proper cost allocation
• Promotional beers can distort margins if not tracked correctly
• Collaborations may involve revenue sharing or licensing issues

Many breweries don’t stumble on creativity — they stumble on execution and measurement.

The CPA Takeaway: Fun Ideas Still Need Smart Numbers

From a financial perspective, novelty beers work best when:

• Costs are intentionally capped
• Expectations are clearly defined upfront
• Performance is measured beyond raw sales
• The release supports broader brand and core-product goals

The biggest mistake breweries make is treating a stunt beer as “just another batch” instead of recognizing it for what it is:

A MARKETING INVESTMENT!

If you wouldn’t launch a paid ad campaign without tracking results, the same logic should apply here.

So… Is Bear Poop Beer a Good Idea?

For the right brand, at the right moment, with the right expectations?

Absolutely.

Not because of the ingredient — but because of the story, timing, and intent behind it.

For everyone else, the lesson isn’t to copy the shock value.

It’s to understand why it works — and how to apply that thinking in ways that make sense for your brewery, your customers, and your financial reality.

Final Thought

Craft beer doesn’t need to be weird to be successful — but it does need to be intentional.

Whether you’re launching a flagship IPA, a seasonal favorite, or a once-in-a-lifetime novelty release, the breweries that win long-term are the ones that:

• Protect their core products
• Experiment strategically
• And back creativity with clear financial strategy

And no — you don’t need bear poop to do that.

Cheers!